Main
Date: 28 Apr 2007 15:44:21
From: [email protected]
Subject: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
[Date "2007.04.28"]
[White "Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32, queen rook removed"]
[Black "novag star sapphire, queen rook pawn removed"]
[Result "*"]
[TimeControl "40/9000:40/9000:40/9000"]
[Termination "unterminated"]
[PlyCount "167"]
[WhiteType "program, analyses by Rybka"]
[BlackType "program"]

1. Nc3 {(Nb1c3 Nb8c6 Ng1f3 d7d6 d2d3 d6d5 Qd1d2 d5d4) -3.87/11 201} d5
2.
e3 {(e2e3 Ng8f6 a2a3 Nb8c6 b2b3 d5d4 Nc3b5 d4xe3 f2xe3 e7e6) -3.87/13
271}
Nf6 3. g3 {(g2g3 c7c6 Bf1d3 Nf6d7 Bd3f1 b7b5 b2b3 e7e5 a2a4) -3.87/12
479}
Ne4 4. Nxe4 {(Nc3xe4 d5xe4 a2a3 Ra8a5 b2b4 Ra5d5 Bf1g2 f7f5 c2c4
Rd5d7)
-3.84/16 212} dxe4 5. a3 {(a2a3 Ra8a5 b2b4 Ra5d5 Bf1g2 f7f5 c2c4 Rd5d7
g3g4
f5xg4) -3.84/16 260} e5 6. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Bc8f5 Ng1e2 Qd8d5 Ne2c3 Qd5c6
Bg2f1
Qc6f6 Bf1g2 Qf6g6) -3.84/16 166} Bf5 7. Ne2 {(Ng1e2 Qd8d5 Ne2c3 Qd5c6
Bg2f1
Qc6f6 Bf1g2 Qf6g6 h2h3 Qg6c6) -3.84/16 131} Qd7 8. h3 {(h2h3 Bf5g6
Ne2c3
Qd7c6 h3h4 h7h6 b2b4 Bf8e7 Bg2f1 Qc6d6) -3.84/17 234} Na6 9. g4 {(g3g4
Bf5g6 Ne2g3 000 00 Bf8e7 Ng3xe4 h7h5 b2b4 h5xg4) -3.58/16 154} Bg6 10.
Ng3
{(Ne2g3 Bf8e7 00 000 Ng3f5 h7h5 Nf5xe7+ Qd7xe7 b2b4 Qe7d6) -3.62/16
332}
Qa4 11. b3 {(b2b3 Qa4c6 00 Na6b8 b3b4 Qc6c4 Ng3xe4 Bg6xe4 d2d3 Be4xd3)
-3.51/16 381} Qa5 12. b4 {(b3b4 Qa5d5 h3h4 h7h6 d2d3 Qd5d7 h4h5 Bg6h7
Ng3xe4 c7c5) -3.13/15 118} Nxb4 13. axb4 {(a3xb4 Qa5xb4 00 Bf8e7 f2f3
Ra8a1
f3xe4 Qb4a4 d2d3 Be7a3) -2.28/15 57} Qxb4 14. O-O {(00 Bf8d6 Ng3f5 00
d2d3
Bg6xf5 g4xf5 e4xd3 Qd1xd3 Rf8d8) -2.43/15 217} Ra1 15. Qe2 {(Qd1e2
Bf8e7
Ng3f5 Bg6xf5 c2c3 Qb4a4 g4xf5 h7h5 d2d4 e4xd3/ep) -2.43/15 213} Be7
16. Nf5
{(Ng3f5 Be7f6 c2c4 Qb4b1 Bc1a3 Qb1a2 Ba3b4 Ra1b1 Bb4c3 Qa2c2) -2.67/15
231}
Bxf5 17. gxf5 {(g4xf5 h7h5 d2d3 e4xd3 Qe2xd3 00 Qd3d7 Qb4c5 f5f6
Be7xf6)
-2.49/16 128} O-O 18. Qg4 {(Qe2g4 Ra1a4 f2f4 e5xf4 Qg4xf4 Qb4c4 Bc1b2
Be7d6
Qf4g4 f7f6) -2.55/15 212} Ra4 19. Rd1 {(Rf1d1 Be7f6 h3h4 h7h6 Kg1h2
Qb4c4
h4h5 Rf8d8 Kh2g3 b7b5) -2.76/15 639} Rfa8 20. f6 {(f5f6 Be7xf6 c2c3
Qb4c4
Kg1h2 h7h5 Qg4xh5 g7g6 Qh5g4 Qc4e6) -2.79/14 146} Bxf6 21. c3 {(c2c3
Qb4c4
Rd1f1 Bf6e7 Kg1h2 Be7a3 Bc1xa3 Ra4xa3 Rf1b1 g7g6) -3.00/15 138} Qb3
22. Rf1
{(Rd1f1 Qb3c4 f2f4 e4xf3/ep Qg4xf3 Ra4a1 Qf3xb7 Ra8d8 Qb7b2 Qc4a2)
-3.09/15
203} Qc2 23. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 h7h5 Kg1h2 Bf6e7 f2f4 e5xf4 Rf1xf4 Be7f6
Rf4f1
Ra4a5) -3.18/15 131} Rd8 24. Bf3 {(Bg2f3 g7g6 Qf5xf6 Rd8d6 Bf3d1)
-3.27/16
196} Qd3 25. Bg2 {(Bf3g2 Bf6e7 c3c4 Ra4xc4 Qf5xe5 Be7f6) -3.48/16 200}
Kh8
26. Kh2 {(Kg1h2 Qd3d7 Qf5h5 Bf6e7 Qh5xf7 Be7a3 Qf7b3 Ba3xc1 Rf1xc1
Rd8f8)
-3.00/16 136} h6 27. Rd1 {(Rf1d1 h6h5 Qf5xh5+ Kh8g8 Qh5g4 b7b5 Rd1g1
Qd3c4
Qg4f5 Kg8f8) -2.91/14 147} Qc2 28. Rg1 {(Rd1g1 b7b5 h3h4 Qc2d3 Kh2g3
Qd3d7
Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Bg2h3 Rd7d3) -2.78/15 200} b6 29. h4 {(h3h4 b6b5 h4h5
Qc2d3
Bg2h3 Ra4a1 Bh3g2 Qd3d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7) -2.76/15 232} Qd3 30. Kg3
{(Kh2g3
Kh8g8 h4h5 Qd3d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Bg2h3 Rd7d6 Bh3f5 Ra4a1) -2.79/15 146}
Qc4
31. h5 {(h4h5 Qc4e6 Bg2xe4 Qe6xf5 Be4xf5 Bf6e7 d2d4 Ra4a1 Kg3g2 e5xd4)
-3.21/15 235} Qd3 32. Bh3 {(Bg2h3 Ra4a1 Rg1h1 Ra1xc1 Rh1xc1 Qd3xd2
Rc1b1
Qd2c2 Rb1g1 Qc2xc3) -2.99/16 293} Qe2 33. Bg2 {(Bh3g2 Qe2c4 Qf5g4
Qc4e6
Qg4e2 Bf6e7 Rg1f1 Qe6f5 Kg3h2 Be7a3) -3.00/16 180} Qc4 34. Qg4 {(Qf5g4
Qc4e6 Qg4d1 Ra4a1 Qd1e2 Bf6e7 Kg3h2 Be7a3 Bc1xa3 Ra1xa3) -3.23/16 239}
Qd3
35. Kh2 {(Kg3h2 Qd3d7 Qg4d1 Bf6h4 Bg2h3 f7f5 Rg1f1 Bh4e7 Bc1b2 Ra4a2)
-2.99/16 178} b5 36. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Qg4f5 Ra4a1 Bf1g2 Qd5e6 Qf5xe6
f7xe6
Bg2xe4 Bf6e7) -3.00/17 318} Qb1 37. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1c2 Bg2h1 Ra4c4
Qg4f5
Qc2d3 Kh2g3 Qd3d7 Bh1xe4 Qd7xf5) -2.79/16 152} Qc2 38. Rd1 {(Rg1d1
Qc2d3
Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Kh2g3 Bf6e7 Bf1g2 Qd5d3 Rd1h1 Be7a3) -2.88/16 383} Be7 39.
Rg1
{(Rd1g1 Be7g5 Qg4f5 Kh8g8 Kh2h1 Qc2d3 Qf5g4 f7f5 Qg4h3 Qd3e2) -2.79/16
242}
Bg5 40. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Kh8g8 Kh2g3 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qf5xd7
Rd8xd7) -2.79/15 196} Bf6 41. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Kh3h2
Ra4a1
Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7) -2.79/16 305} Qd3 42. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5
Qf5g4
Ra4a1 Bf1g2 Ra1xc1 Rg1xc1 Qd5xd2 Rc1f1 Kh8g8) -3.05/17 244} Qb1 43.
Bg2
{(Bf1g2 Qb1a2 Bg2xe4 Qa2e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 d2d3 Ra4a2 Rg1d1 Ra2xf2)
-2.79/18
262} c5 44. Kh2 {(Kh3h2 Qb1d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1xb5 Ra4a1 c3c4 Qd5b7
Bc1b2
Ra1xg1) -2.78/17 224} Qc2 45. Rh1 {(Rg1h1 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2
Qd5d7
Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Rh1f1 Rd7a7) -2.79/16 150} Kg8 46. Rg1 {(Rh1g1 Kg8f8
Qf5g4
Ra4c4 Qg4e2 Kf8g8 Kh2h3 Bf6g5 Kh3g3 Rd8d3) -2.79/16 141} Kf8 47. Qg4
{(Qf5g4 Ra4c4 Qg4e2 Kf8g8 Kh2h3 Bf6g5 Kh3g3 f7f5 Kg3h2 Rc4a4) -2.97/16
211}
Qd3 48. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 Qd5c4 Rg1d1 Ra1a4 d2d4
Qc4xc3)
-3.14/15 166} Qb1 49. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 Qb1a2 Be4c6 Qa2c4
Qg4xc4
b5xc4 Bc6e4 Kf8e7) -2.95/15 203} Qc2 50. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4
Qc2a2
Be4f5 Qa2a4 Bf5e4 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4) -3.23/15 242} Kg8 51. Kh2 {(Kh3h2
Qc2b3
Rg1d1 Qb3e6 Qg4xe6 f7xe6 Kh2g3 Kg8f7 Bg2f1 b5b4) -2.79/15 117} Qd3 52.
Bf1
{(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qg4e2 Bf6g5 Rg1f1 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 f7f5)
-2.94/16
232} Qb1 53. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1b3 Qg4f5 Qb3e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Kh2g3 Bf6g5
Rg1f1
Kg8h7) -2.79/16 239} Bg5 54. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Qb1d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d6 Bf1xb5
Ra4a5
Bb5c4 Qd6f6 Qf5xf6 Bg5xf6) -2.79/15 126} Be7 55. Qg4 {(Qf5g4 Be7f6
Qg4f5
Qb1b3 Bg2xe4 Qb3e6 Qf5f3 Bf6g5 Kh2g2 Qe6c4) -2.79/16 620} Bf8 56. Qf5
{(Qg4f5 Rd8d6 Bg2f3 Qb1c2 Bf3g2 g7g6 h5xg6 Rd6xg6 f2f4 e5xf4) -2.73/15
150}
Qc2 57. Kh1 {(Kh2h1 Bf8e7 Qf5g4 Be7g5 Qg4f5 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2
Qd5e6)
-2.79/16 216} Rd6 58. Kh2 {(Kh1h2 g7g6 h5xg6 Rd6xg6 Qf5c8 Qc2d3 Bg2f1
Qd3d6
Bf1g2 Qd6f6) -3.17/16 140} Rda6 59. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Ra4c4 Qf5d7 Ra6f6
Qd7xb5
Rc4a4 Qb5b7 Rf6xf2 Kh3g3 Rf2f5) -3.25/16 262} Re6 60. Kh2 {(Kh3h2
Ra4c4
Bg2f1 Re6a6 Bf1h3 Ra6a8 Qf5d7 Rc4a4 Bh3f5 Qc2d3) -2.79/16 153} Be7 61.
Qg4
{(Qf5g4 Be7g5 Rg1f1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4 Bg2xe4 b4b3 Be4xc2 Ra4xg4)
-2.69/15
161} Bg5 62. Rf1 {(Rg1f1 Qc2d3 Rf1e1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4 Qg4f5 Qd3d7
Re1g1
Re6d6) -2.79/15 221} Bd8 63. Rg1 {(Rf1g1 g7g5 Rg1f1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4
Bg2xe4
b4b3 Be4xc2 Ra4xg4) -2.74/15 259} Bf6 64. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Bf6g5 Qf5g4
Qc2d3
Bg2f1 Qd3d7 Bf1g2 Re6d6 Qg4xd7 Rd6xd7) -2.79/15 187} Bg5 65. Rf1
{(Rg1f1
Ra4c4 Rf1g1 b5b4 Bg2f1) -2.72/15 583} Be7 66. Qg4 {(Qf5g4 Re6f6 Kh2g3
Rf6f3+ Bg2xf3 e4xf3 Qg4xf3 Ra4a1 Qf3b7 Be7d6) -3.10/15 212} Bf8 67.
Kg3
{(Kh2g3 g7g6 Kg3h3 f7f5 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1 g6xh5 Bg2f1 c5c4) -3.33/16
400}
Rea6 68. Kh2 {(Kg3h2 Ra6f6 Kh2g1 Rf6f3 Bg2xf3 e4xf3 Qg4xf3 b5b4 c3xb4
c5xb4) -3.74/15 140} Rd6 69. Kg3 {(Kh2g3 g7g6 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1
g6xh5
Kg3h2 Rd6f6 Rd1f1 Rf6g6) -3.59/16 319} Qd3 70. Re1 {(Rf1e1 Rd6f6 Bg2f1
Qd3c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 c5c4 Bc1b2 Ra4a2) -3.27/15 139} Rf6 71. Bf1
{(Bg2f1 Qd3c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 c5c4 Bc1b2 Ra4a2 Rd1b1 Rf6f5)
-3.33/16
116} Qb1 72. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 Rf6f5 Bg2f1 Rf5g5+
Kg3h2
Rg5xh5+) -3.60/15 157} Qc2 73. Qd1 {(Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 Rf6f5 d2d4
Rf5g5+
Kg3h3 Rg5xh5+ Kh3g4 Rh5g5+) -3.99/16 284} Qd3 74. Qg4 {(Qd1g4 Rf6f4
Qg4h3
f7f5 Kg3h2 Rf4xf2 Kh2g1 Rf2xg2+ Qh3xg2 Qd3d7) -3.75/15 143} Qb1 75.
Rf1
{(Re1f1 Qb1c2 Bg2h1 Qc2d3 Rf1e1 Rf6f4 Qg4e2 Qd3xe2 Re1xe2 Rf4f5)
-3.60/15
277} Qc2 76. Qd1 {(Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1 Rf6f5 d2d4 e5xd4 e3xd4 Bf8d6+
Kg3g4
Rf5xf2) -3.93/15 148} Qd3 77. Bb2 {(Bc1b2 Rf6f5 Kg3h2 Ra4a2 Bb2c1
Ra2a1
Bg2h3 Ra1xc1) -4.06/15 244} Ra2 78. Qb1 {(Qd1b1 Qd3c4 Bb2c1 Rf6f5 f2f4
e4xf3/ep Qb1xf5 f3xg2 Kg3xg2 b5b4) -3.87/16 182} Rxf2 79. Kxf2
{(Kg3xf2
Qd3xd2+ Kf2g3 Qd2xb2 Qb1xb2 Ra2xb2 Bg2xe4 Rb2d2 c3c4 b5xc4) -3.44/17
113}
Qxd2 80. Kg3 {(Kf2g3 Qd2xb2 Qb1xb2 Ra2xb2 Bg2xe4 Rb2d2 Rf1f2 Rd2d1
Rf2a2
b5b4) -3.44/18 337} Rxb2 81. Qxe4 {(Qb1xe4 b5b4 Qe4f3 Qd2d7 Qf3d5
Rb2d2
Qd5xd7 Rd2xd7 Rf1b1 Rd7d2) -3.70/15 82} Qxc3 82. Kh3 {(Kg3h3 Rb2e2
Qe4d5
Re2xe3+ Kh3h2 Qc3c4 Qd5xc4 b5xc4 Bg2d5 c4c3) -3.50/15 238} Rd2 83. Qf5
{(Qe4f5 Qc3b3 Bg2e4 Qb3e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Be4c6 b5b4 Bc6e8 e5e4) -3.50/16
217}
Qc4 84. Bc6 {(Bg2c6 Qc4a2 Bc6e4 Qa2e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Be4c6 b5b4 Bc6e8
e5e4)
-3.50/16 228} * game terminated after 6 hours.





 
Date: 30 Apr 2007 11:38:35
From: David Richerby
Subject: Re: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
[email protected] <[email protected] > wrote:
> [Date "2007.04.28"]
> [White "Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32, queen rook removed"]
> [Black "novag star sapphire, queen rook pawn removed"]
> [Result "*"]
> [TimeControl "40/9000:40/9000:40/9000"]
> [Termination "unterminated"]
> [PlyCount "167"]
> [WhiteType "program, analyses by Rybka"]
> [BlackType "program"]

If you add the following PGN tags, PGN readers can set up the position
automatically:

[Setup "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/1ppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]


Dave.

--
David Richerby Transparent Carnivorous Tongs (TM):
www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~davidr/ it's like a pair of tongs but it's
full of teeth and you can see right
through it!


 
Date: 28 Apr 2007 22:55:52
From: SAT W-7
Subject: Re: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
amazing game



 
Date: 28 Apr 2007 17:20:35
From: JohnnyT
Subject: Re: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
A few observations, I am still vastly curious of the why. I am also
highly suspicious of the whole black has it's queen rook pawn removed.
If they both have it removed, isn't Rxa8 on the first move?

Finally, the beta version of Rybka, is famously broken in endgames. So
it kind of makes the why interesting.

But you should be able to locate Fruit 2.1 if you insist on not paying
any money. Toga is good as well. I believe. Which should give the
Novag at least as good a run for it's money, and it won't be broken at
the end. I think.

[email protected] wrote:
> [Date "2007.04.28"]
> [White "Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32, queen rook removed"]
> [Black "novag star sapphire, queen rook pawn removed"]
> [Result "*"]
> [TimeControl "40/9000:40/9000:40/9000"]
> [Termination "unterminated"]
> [PlyCount "167"]
> [WhiteType "program, analyses by Rybka"]
> [BlackType "program"]
>
> 1. Nc3 {(Nb1c3 Nb8c6 Ng1f3 d7d6 d2d3 d6d5 Qd1d2 d5d4) -3.87/11 201} d5
> 2.
> e3 {(e2e3 Ng8f6 a2a3 Nb8c6 b2b3 d5d4 Nc3b5 d4xe3 f2xe3 e7e6) -3.87/13
> 271}
> Nf6 3. g3 {(g2g3 c7c6 Bf1d3 Nf6d7 Bd3f1 b7b5 b2b3 e7e5 a2a4) -3.87/12
> 479}
> Ne4 4. Nxe4 {(Nc3xe4 d5xe4 a2a3 Ra8a5 b2b4 Ra5d5 Bf1g2 f7f5 c2c4
> Rd5d7)
> -3.84/16 212} dxe4 5. a3 {(a2a3 Ra8a5 b2b4 Ra5d5 Bf1g2 f7f5 c2c4 Rd5d7
> g3g4
> f5xg4) -3.84/16 260} e5 6. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Bc8f5 Ng1e2 Qd8d5 Ne2c3 Qd5c6
> Bg2f1
> Qc6f6 Bf1g2 Qf6g6) -3.84/16 166} Bf5 7. Ne2 {(Ng1e2 Qd8d5 Ne2c3 Qd5c6
> Bg2f1
> Qc6f6 Bf1g2 Qf6g6 h2h3 Qg6c6) -3.84/16 131} Qd7 8. h3 {(h2h3 Bf5g6
> Ne2c3
> Qd7c6 h3h4 h7h6 b2b4 Bf8e7 Bg2f1 Qc6d6) -3.84/17 234} Na6 9. g4 {(g3g4
> Bf5g6 Ne2g3 000 00 Bf8e7 Ng3xe4 h7h5 b2b4 h5xg4) -3.58/16 154} Bg6 10.
> Ng3
> {(Ne2g3 Bf8e7 00 000 Ng3f5 h7h5 Nf5xe7+ Qd7xe7 b2b4 Qe7d6) -3.62/16
> 332}
> Qa4 11. b3 {(b2b3 Qa4c6 00 Na6b8 b3b4 Qc6c4 Ng3xe4 Bg6xe4 d2d3 Be4xd3)
> -3.51/16 381} Qa5 12. b4 {(b3b4 Qa5d5 h3h4 h7h6 d2d3 Qd5d7 h4h5 Bg6h7
> Ng3xe4 c7c5) -3.13/15 118} Nxb4 13. axb4 {(a3xb4 Qa5xb4 00 Bf8e7 f2f3
> Ra8a1
> f3xe4 Qb4a4 d2d3 Be7a3) -2.28/15 57} Qxb4 14. O-O {(00 Bf8d6 Ng3f5 00
> d2d3
> Bg6xf5 g4xf5 e4xd3 Qd1xd3 Rf8d8) -2.43/15 217} Ra1 15. Qe2 {(Qd1e2
> Bf8e7
> Ng3f5 Bg6xf5 c2c3 Qb4a4 g4xf5 h7h5 d2d4 e4xd3/ep) -2.43/15 213} Be7
> 16. Nf5
> {(Ng3f5 Be7f6 c2c4 Qb4b1 Bc1a3 Qb1a2 Ba3b4 Ra1b1 Bb4c3 Qa2c2) -2.67/15
> 231}
> Bxf5 17. gxf5 {(g4xf5 h7h5 d2d3 e4xd3 Qe2xd3 00 Qd3d7 Qb4c5 f5f6
> Be7xf6)
> -2.49/16 128} O-O 18. Qg4 {(Qe2g4 Ra1a4 f2f4 e5xf4 Qg4xf4 Qb4c4 Bc1b2
> Be7d6
> Qf4g4 f7f6) -2.55/15 212} Ra4 19. Rd1 {(Rf1d1 Be7f6 h3h4 h7h6 Kg1h2
> Qb4c4
> h4h5 Rf8d8 Kh2g3 b7b5) -2.76/15 639} Rfa8 20. f6 {(f5f6 Be7xf6 c2c3
> Qb4c4
> Kg1h2 h7h5 Qg4xh5 g7g6 Qh5g4 Qc4e6) -2.79/14 146} Bxf6 21. c3 {(c2c3
> Qb4c4
> Rd1f1 Bf6e7 Kg1h2 Be7a3 Bc1xa3 Ra4xa3 Rf1b1 g7g6) -3.00/15 138} Qb3
> 22. Rf1
> {(Rd1f1 Qb3c4 f2f4 e4xf3/ep Qg4xf3 Ra4a1 Qf3xb7 Ra8d8 Qb7b2 Qc4a2)
> -3.09/15
> 203} Qc2 23. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 h7h5 Kg1h2 Bf6e7 f2f4 e5xf4 Rf1xf4 Be7f6
> Rf4f1
> Ra4a5) -3.18/15 131} Rd8 24. Bf3 {(Bg2f3 g7g6 Qf5xf6 Rd8d6 Bf3d1)
> -3.27/16
> 196} Qd3 25. Bg2 {(Bf3g2 Bf6e7 c3c4 Ra4xc4 Qf5xe5 Be7f6) -3.48/16 200}
> Kh8
> 26. Kh2 {(Kg1h2 Qd3d7 Qf5h5 Bf6e7 Qh5xf7 Be7a3 Qf7b3 Ba3xc1 Rf1xc1
> Rd8f8)
> -3.00/16 136} h6 27. Rd1 {(Rf1d1 h6h5 Qf5xh5+ Kh8g8 Qh5g4 b7b5 Rd1g1
> Qd3c4
> Qg4f5 Kg8f8) -2.91/14 147} Qc2 28. Rg1 {(Rd1g1 b7b5 h3h4 Qc2d3 Kh2g3
> Qd3d7
> Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Bg2h3 Rd7d3) -2.78/15 200} b6 29. h4 {(h3h4 b6b5 h4h5
> Qc2d3
> Bg2h3 Ra4a1 Bh3g2 Qd3d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7) -2.76/15 232} Qd3 30. Kg3
> {(Kh2g3
> Kh8g8 h4h5 Qd3d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Bg2h3 Rd7d6 Bh3f5 Ra4a1) -2.79/15 146}
> Qc4
> 31. h5 {(h4h5 Qc4e6 Bg2xe4 Qe6xf5 Be4xf5 Bf6e7 d2d4 Ra4a1 Kg3g2 e5xd4)
> -3.21/15 235} Qd3 32. Bh3 {(Bg2h3 Ra4a1 Rg1h1 Ra1xc1 Rh1xc1 Qd3xd2
> Rc1b1
> Qd2c2 Rb1g1 Qc2xc3) -2.99/16 293} Qe2 33. Bg2 {(Bh3g2 Qe2c4 Qf5g4
> Qc4e6
> Qg4e2 Bf6e7 Rg1f1 Qe6f5 Kg3h2 Be7a3) -3.00/16 180} Qc4 34. Qg4 {(Qf5g4
> Qc4e6 Qg4d1 Ra4a1 Qd1e2 Bf6e7 Kg3h2 Be7a3 Bc1xa3 Ra1xa3) -3.23/16 239}
> Qd3
> 35. Kh2 {(Kg3h2 Qd3d7 Qg4d1 Bf6h4 Bg2h3 f7f5 Rg1f1 Bh4e7 Bc1b2 Ra4a2)
> -2.99/16 178} b5 36. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Qg4f5 Ra4a1 Bf1g2 Qd5e6 Qf5xe6
> f7xe6
> Bg2xe4 Bf6e7) -3.00/17 318} Qb1 37. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1c2 Bg2h1 Ra4c4
> Qg4f5
> Qc2d3 Kh2g3 Qd3d7 Bh1xe4 Qd7xf5) -2.79/16 152} Qc2 38. Rd1 {(Rg1d1
> Qc2d3
> Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Kh2g3 Bf6e7 Bf1g2 Qd5d3 Rd1h1 Be7a3) -2.88/16 383} Be7 39.
> Rg1
> {(Rd1g1 Be7g5 Qg4f5 Kh8g8 Kh2h1 Qc2d3 Qf5g4 f7f5 Qg4h3 Qd3e2) -2.79/16
> 242}
> Bg5 40. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Kh8g8 Kh2g3 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qf5xd7
> Rd8xd7) -2.79/15 196} Bf6 41. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Kh3h2
> Ra4a1
> Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7) -2.79/16 305} Qd3 42. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5
> Qf5g4
> Ra4a1 Bf1g2 Ra1xc1 Rg1xc1 Qd5xd2 Rc1f1 Kh8g8) -3.05/17 244} Qb1 43.
> Bg2
> {(Bf1g2 Qb1a2 Bg2xe4 Qa2e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 d2d3 Ra4a2 Rg1d1 Ra2xf2)
> -2.79/18
> 262} c5 44. Kh2 {(Kh3h2 Qb1d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1xb5 Ra4a1 c3c4 Qd5b7
> Bc1b2
> Ra1xg1) -2.78/17 224} Qc2 45. Rh1 {(Rg1h1 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2
> Qd5d7
> Qf5xd7 Rd8xd7 Rh1f1 Rd7a7) -2.79/16 150} Kg8 46. Rg1 {(Rh1g1 Kg8f8
> Qf5g4
> Ra4c4 Qg4e2 Kf8g8 Kh2h3 Bf6g5 Kh3g3 Rd8d3) -2.79/16 141} Kf8 47. Qg4
> {(Qf5g4 Ra4c4 Qg4e2 Kf8g8 Kh2h3 Bf6g5 Kh3g3 f7f5 Kg3h2 Rc4a4) -2.97/16
> 211}
> Qd3 48. Bf1 {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 Qd5c4 Rg1d1 Ra1a4 d2d4
> Qc4xc3)
> -3.14/15 166} Qb1 49. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 Qb1a2 Be4c6 Qa2c4
> Qg4xc4
> b5xc4 Bc6e4 Kf8e7) -2.95/15 203} Qc2 50. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4
> Qc2a2
> Be4f5 Qa2a4 Bf5e4 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4) -3.23/15 242} Kg8 51. Kh2 {(Kh3h2
> Qc2b3
> Rg1d1 Qb3e6 Qg4xe6 f7xe6 Kh2g3 Kg8f7 Bg2f1 b5b4) -2.79/15 117} Qd3 52.
> Bf1
> {(Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2 Qd5d7 Qg4e2 Bf6g5 Rg1f1 Ra4a1 Bg2xe4 f7f5)
> -2.94/16
> 232} Qb1 53. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1b3 Qg4f5 Qb3e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Kh2g3 Bf6g5
> Rg1f1
> Kg8h7) -2.79/16 239} Bg5 54. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Qb1d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d6 Bf1xb5
> Ra4a5
> Bb5c4 Qd6f6 Qf5xf6 Bg5xf6) -2.79/15 126} Be7 55. Qg4 {(Qf5g4 Be7f6
> Qg4f5
> Qb1b3 Bg2xe4 Qb3e6 Qf5f3 Bf6g5 Kh2g2 Qe6c4) -2.79/16 620} Bf8 56. Qf5
> {(Qg4f5 Rd8d6 Bg2f3 Qb1c2 Bf3g2 g7g6 h5xg6 Rd6xg6 f2f4 e5xf4) -2.73/15
> 150}
> Qc2 57. Kh1 {(Kh2h1 Bf8e7 Qf5g4 Be7g5 Qg4f5 Qc2d3 Bg2f1 Qd3d5 Bf1g2
> Qd5e6)
> -2.79/16 216} Rd6 58. Kh2 {(Kh1h2 g7g6 h5xg6 Rd6xg6 Qf5c8 Qc2d3 Bg2f1
> Qd3d6
> Bf1g2 Qd6f6) -3.17/16 140} Rda6 59. Kh3 {(Kh2h3 Ra4c4 Qf5d7 Ra6f6
> Qd7xb5
> Rc4a4 Qb5b7 Rf6xf2 Kh3g3 Rf2f5) -3.25/16 262} Re6 60. Kh2 {(Kh3h2
> Ra4c4
> Bg2f1 Re6a6 Bf1h3 Ra6a8 Qf5d7 Rc4a4 Bh3f5 Qc2d3) -2.79/16 153} Be7 61.
> Qg4
> {(Qf5g4 Be7g5 Rg1f1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4 Bg2xe4 b4b3 Be4xc2 Ra4xg4)
> -2.69/15
> 161} Bg5 62. Rf1 {(Rg1f1 Qc2d3 Rf1e1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4 Qg4f5 Qd3d7
> Re1g1
> Re6d6) -2.79/15 221} Bd8 63. Rg1 {(Rf1g1 g7g5 Rg1f1 b5b4 c3xb4 c5xb4
> Bg2xe4
> b4b3 Be4xc2 Ra4xg4) -2.74/15 259} Bf6 64. Qf5 {(Qg4f5 Bf6g5 Qf5g4
> Qc2d3
> Bg2f1 Qd3d7 Bf1g2 Re6d6 Qg4xd7 Rd6xd7) -2.79/15 187} Bg5 65. Rf1
> {(Rg1f1
> Ra4c4 Rf1g1 b5b4 Bg2f1) -2.72/15 583} Be7 66. Qg4 {(Qf5g4 Re6f6 Kh2g3
> Rf6f3+ Bg2xf3 e4xf3 Qg4xf3 Ra4a1 Qf3b7 Be7d6) -3.10/15 212} Bf8 67.
> Kg3
> {(Kh2g3 g7g6 Kg3h3 f7f5 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1 g6xh5 Bg2f1 c5c4) -3.33/16
> 400}
> Rea6 68. Kh2 {(Kg3h2 Ra6f6 Kh2g1 Rf6f3 Bg2xf3 e4xf3 Qg4xf3 b5b4 c3xb4
> c5xb4) -3.74/15 140} Rd6 69. Kg3 {(Kh2g3 g7g6 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1
> g6xh5
> Kg3h2 Rd6f6 Rd1f1 Rf6g6) -3.59/16 319} Qd3 70. Re1 {(Rf1e1 Rd6f6 Bg2f1
> Qd3c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 c5c4 Bc1b2 Ra4a2) -3.27/15 139} Rf6 71. Bf1
> {(Bg2f1 Qd3c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 c5c4 Bc1b2 Ra4a2 Rd1b1 Rf6f5)
> -3.33/16
> 116} Qb1 72. Bg2 {(Bf1g2 Qb1c2 Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 Rf6f5 Bg2f1 Rf5g5+
> Kg3h2
> Rg5xh5+) -3.60/15 157} Qc2 73. Qd1 {(Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Re1xd1 Rf6f5 d2d4
> Rf5g5+
> Kg3h3 Rg5xh5+ Kh3g4 Rh5g5+) -3.99/16 284} Qd3 74. Qg4 {(Qd1g4 Rf6f4
> Qg4h3
> f7f5 Kg3h2 Rf4xf2 Kh2g1 Rf2xg2+ Qh3xg2 Qd3d7) -3.75/15 143} Qb1 75.
> Rf1
> {(Re1f1 Qb1c2 Bg2h1 Qc2d3 Rf1e1 Rf6f4 Qg4e2 Qd3xe2 Re1xe2 Rf4f5)
> -3.60/15
> 277} Qc2 76. Qd1 {(Qg4d1 Qc2xd1 Rf1xd1 Rf6f5 d2d4 e5xd4 e3xd4 Bf8d6+
> Kg3g4
> Rf5xf2) -3.93/15 148} Qd3 77. Bb2 {(Bc1b2 Rf6f5 Kg3h2 Ra4a2 Bb2c1
> Ra2a1
> Bg2h3 Ra1xc1) -4.06/15 244} Ra2 78. Qb1 {(Qd1b1 Qd3c4 Bb2c1 Rf6f5 f2f4
> e4xf3/ep Qb1xf5 f3xg2 Kg3xg2 b5b4) -3.87/16 182} Rxf2 79. Kxf2
> {(Kg3xf2
> Qd3xd2+ Kf2g3 Qd2xb2 Qb1xb2 Ra2xb2 Bg2xe4 Rb2d2 c3c4 b5xc4) -3.44/17
> 113}
> Qxd2 80. Kg3 {(Kf2g3 Qd2xb2 Qb1xb2 Ra2xb2 Bg2xe4 Rb2d2 Rf1f2 Rd2d1
> Rf2a2
> b5b4) -3.44/18 337} Rxb2 81. Qxe4 {(Qb1xe4 b5b4 Qe4f3 Qd2d7 Qf3d5
> Rb2d2
> Qd5xd7 Rd2xd7 Rf1b1 Rd7d2) -3.70/15 82} Qxc3 82. Kh3 {(Kg3h3 Rb2e2
> Qe4d5
> Re2xe3+ Kh3h2 Qc3c4 Qd5xc4 b5xc4 Bg2d5 c4c3) -3.50/15 238} Rd2 83. Qf5
> {(Qe4f5 Qc3b3 Bg2e4 Qb3e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Be4c6 b5b4 Bc6e8 e5e4) -3.50/16
> 217}
> Qc4 84. Bc6 {(Bg2c6 Qc4a2 Bc6e4 Qa2e6 Qf5xe6 f7xe6 Be4c6 b5b4 Bc6e8
> e5e4)
> -3.50/16 228} * game terminated after 6 hours.
>


  
Date: 30 Apr 2007 11:36:57
From: David Richerby
Subject: Re: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
JohnnyT <[email protected] > wrote:
>[email protected] wrote:
>> [Date "2007.04.28"]
>> [White "Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32, queen rook removed"]
>> [Black "novag star sapphire, queen rook pawn removed"]
>
> A few observations, I am still vastly curious of the why. I am also
> highly suspicious of the whole black has it's queen rook pawn removed.
> If they both have it removed, isn't Rxa8 on the first move?

White has his queen's rook removed; black has his queen's rook's pawn.


Dave.

--
David Richerby Impossible Chainsaw (TM): it's like
www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~davidr/ a lethal weapon but it can't exist!


   
Date: 30 Apr 2007 09:22:51
From: JohnnyT
Subject: Re: Rybka No Rook Vs. Novag Star Sapphire No Rook Pawn
David Richerby wrote:
> JohnnyT <[email protected]> wrote:
>> [email protected] wrote:
>>> [Date "2007.04.28"]
>>> [White "Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32, queen rook removed"]
>>> [Black "novag star sapphire, queen rook pawn removed"]
>> A few observations, I am still vastly curious of the why. I am also
>> highly suspicious of the whole black has it's queen rook pawn removed.
>> If they both have it removed, isn't Rxa8 on the first move?
>
> White has his queen's rook removed; black has his queen's rook's pawn.
>
>
> Dave.
>

Thanks.